On 13 Nov 2003, Pat LaVarre wrote:
> I mean to be saying sd.c should by default send the CDB's associated
> with buffer lengths that produce the same BBB CBW's as Windows XP/2K,
> and then determine the read/write status and cache-type from that info
> alone.
>
> Do you agree that works for generic USB storage i.e. bInterfaceClass
> ...SubClass ...Protocol = x 08 (02|05|06) 50?
>
> Do you disagree that is what we should do in sd for generic USB storage?
>
> I'm confident Win XP/2K sometimes sends mode select to PDT x00
> HDD/Flash, because I remember some months back a friend fixed some
> firmware that didn't interpret mode select like Win wants nowadays.
>
> I imagine that means Win sends mode sense too.
>
> I haven't yet seen a trace of Win XP/2K.
Trying to rely too heavily on Talk Like Windows may be a mistake, since
Windows itself seems to use different dialects in its different versions.
It reminds me of the mess Microsoft had with their SMB file-sharing
network protocol; different versions of Windows were so incompatible they
often couldn't communicate among themselves.
CDs, DVDs, etc. present their own set of problems. For the moment I'm
just concerned about disk-type devices, and the only reliable way I can
see to deal with them is to avoid sending any MODE-SENSE commands over
USB.
Unfortunately that does mean we lose the ability to tell if a compliant
device/media is write-protected. You suggested allowing MODE-SENSE
commands for devices that present certain standard SubClass and Protocol
values, or disallowing them only for devices that present vendor-specific
values. I'm not so sure that will work -- I haven't kept good records of
users' reports, but it wouldn't be at all surprising to find that some
apparently-compliant devices (bInterfaceSubClass = x06, Protocol = x50)
still have problems with MODE-SENSE.
Alan Stern
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-scsi" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
|
