logo       

Is the derivability sign a metalinguistic sign?: msg#00150

Subject: Is the derivability sign a metalinguistic sign?
Dear Fomers,

A simple problem about language and metalanguage in formal theory. It is 
usually stated that |- (sign of derivability) is a metalinguistic sign denoting 
(in a sequent calculus) a relation between sets of formulas and formulas. In 
this case, the relata should be metalinguistic signs as well. But in a simple 
derivation like this:

        |- 0 = 0

the string of signs on the right is a linguistic one, isn't it? Actually, "0 = 
0" is an element of the language and the name just written is a metalinguistic 
name for that object. Thus, we have a matalinguistic string consisting in a 
metalinguistic relation sign and a linguistic string. Is it possible?

Alessandro Giordani & Ciro De Florio


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>