Science.linguistics.citizendium.general Recent Discussions

science.linguistics.citizendium.general (thread)

On the evidence for the majority of WP articles being good quality
Triage and formatting
- Re: Triage and formatting
Why we should fork all at once
- Re: Why we should fork all at once
- Re: Why we should fork all at once
forking, citation, depth
- Re: forking, citation, depth
Citizendium fork Wikipedia piecemeal? - Triage
- Re: Citizendium fork Wikipedia piecemeal? - Triage
Proposal: A triage process for articles forked from Wikipedia.
Challenges of an all-at-once fork
Launching piecemeal or all at once
- Launching piecemeal or all at once
Citizendium launch plan as of September 26
New list moderation rules, shorter this time
Test post, please ignore
Larry asks: are WP's philosophy articles really that bad now?
Re: Knowing your customer....targetting article depth.
Re: Citizendium-l Digest, Vol 1, Issue 77
Knowing your customer....targetting article depth.
- Re: Knowing your customer....targetting article depth.
- Re: Knowing your customer ... targetting article depth
Please read: new forums, and changing the mailing list format
Re: Let's get structure!
Should the Citizendium fork Wikipedia piecemeal or all at once?
- Should the Citizendium fork Wikipedia piecemeal or all at once?
  - Re: Should the Citizendium fork Wikipedia piecemeal or all at once?
    - Re: Should the Citizendium fork Wikipedia piecemeal or all at once?
    - Re: Should the Citizendium fork Wikipedia piecemeal or all at once?
- Should the Citizendium fork Wikipedia piecemeal or all at once?
Some thoughts
Transversality and 2) Fork Viability
Added wiki page with links and description of mailing lists
- Re: CZML -> CZ DIS
  - Re: CZML -> CZ DIS
  - Re: CZML -> CZ DIS
avoid exclusion factor of overly academic and/or insider language
- Re: avoid exclusion factor of overly academic and/or insider language
  - Re: avoid exclusion factor of overly academic and/or insider language
- avoid exclusion factor of overly academic and/or insider language
Re: Citizendium will not resolve all major issues from Wikipedia
- Re: Citizendium will not resolve all major issues from Wikipedia
  - Re: Citizendium will not resolve all major issues from Wikipedia
    - Re: Citizendium will not resolve all major issues from Wikipedia
    - Re: Citizendium will not resolve all major issues from Wikipedia
- Re: Citizendium will not resolve all major issues from Wikipedia
  - Re: Citizendium will not resolve all major issues from Wikipedia
  - Re: Citizendium will not resolve all major issues from Wikipedia
On Transversality -- Communication Between Different Levels Of Experience
- Re: On Transversality -- Communication Between Different Levels Of Experience
  - Re: On Transversality -- Communication Between Different Levels Of Experience
    - Re: On Transversality -- Communication Between Different Levels Of Experience
    - Transversality -- Communication Across Levels Of Experience
  - Re: On Transversality -- Communication Between Different Levels Of Experience
    - Re: On Transversality -- Communication Between Different Levels Of Experience
    - Re: On Transversality -- Communication Between Different Levels Of Experience
- Re: On Transversality -- Communication Between Different Levels Of Experience
  - Re: On Transversality -- Communication Between Different Levels Of Experience
Setting up Citizendium
- Re: Setting up Citizendium
Citizendium will not resolve all major issues from Wikipedia
Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia? Level!
- Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia? Level!
Re: Citizendium-l Digest, Vol 1, Issue 62
Compendium Improvement Process
Cranks and trolls
Selecting editors by CZ peers, see writing.com
Constables, Wikipedia admins and trolls
- Re: Constables, Wikipedia admins and trolls
- Re: Constables, Admins, and Trolls
Re: The middle road - Constables, editors, and the Citizendium Foundation
Re: No Constable, I'm an Aedile
Here's a challenge
- Re: Here's a challenge
  - Re: Here's a challenge
  - Re: Here's a challenge
    - Too late abed [was Re: Here's a challenge]
Publishing articles vs approving
No Constable, I'm an Aedile.
- Re: No Constable, I'm an Aedile
  - Re: Aediles of the King
Constables?
- Re: Constables?
Re: The Main Page
- Re: The Main Page
From the talk page Wiki on Citi.
Re: Constables, editors, and the Citizendium Foundation
Citizendium on Wikipedia
- Re: Citizendium on Wikipedia
  - Re: Citizendium on Wikipedia
    - Re: Citizendium on Wikipedia
    - Re: Citizendium on Wikipedia
Constables, editors, and the Citizendium Foundation
- Re: Constables, editors, and the Citizendium Foundation
- Constables, editors, and the Citizendium Foundation
Re: sysop proposal for Larry; the 300
- Re: sysop proposal for Larry; the 300
What should be fixed based on the WP experience
- Re: What should be fixed based on the WP experience
What's wrong with Wikipedia?
- Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia?
  - Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia?
    - Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia?
- What's wrong with Wikipedia?
  - Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia?
- Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia?
  - Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia?
- What's wrong with Wikipedia?
  - Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia?
- Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia?
  - Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia?
- Re: What's wrong with Wikipedia?
Breakpoint 4. No More Fairy Tales
- Re: Breakpoint 4. No More Fairy Tales
What happens when there are no experts?
- Re: What happens when there are no experts?
What makes a good editor?
Re: Measuring Expertise - Contextual Authority Tagging
- Re: Measuring Expertise - Contextual Authority Tagging
  - Re: Measuring Expertise - Contextual Authority Tagging
WP-style categories
- Re: WP-style categories
Call for assistance!
That deadline
- Re: That deadline
  - Re: That deadline
- Re: That deadline
- Re: That deadline
  - Re: That deadline
    - Re: That deadline
  - Re: That deadline
    - Re: That deadline
    - Re: That deadline
    - Re: That deadline
- Re: That deadline
- Re: That deadline
  - Re: That deadline
    - Re: That deadline
    - Re: That deadline
- Re: That deadline
  - Re: That deadline
- Re: That deadline
  - Re: That deadline
    - Re: That deadline
MediaWiki extensions
Demo sites
- Re: Demo sites
  - Re: Demo sites
In regards to identity . . .
Gmane & vBulletin
- Re: Gmane & vBulletin
  - Re: Gmane & vBulletin
- Re: Gmane & vBulletin
Re: Limit posts per day, migrate most traffic to Web forums?
How to save time reading mailing lists
thoughts on pre-launch
- Re: thoughts on pre-launch
  - Re: thoughts on pre-launch
  - Re: thoughts on pre-launch
    - Re: thoughts on pre-launch
    - Re: thoughts on pre-launch
  - Re: thoughts on pre-launch
    - Newsreader
    - Re: Newsreader
- Re: thoughts on pre-launch
- Re: thoughts on pre-launch
  - Re: thoughts on pre-launch
    - Re: thoughts on pre-launch
EoE contributor policy
EoE is now online
NPOV
- Re: NPOV
- Re: NPOV
- Re: NPOV
  - Re: NPOV
Re: Babysitting
Measuring Expertise - Contextual Authority Tagging
- Re: Measuring Expertise - Contextual Authority Tagging
Its no expert v. non-expert, its NPOV.
Watching with interest
Objectivity vs. Expertise
a priori disambiguation (was: Re: reliability, homonyms, content, sources, editors, multinationals)
Exporting articles + forking back is not our problem
inter-article links (was Re: reliability, homonyms, content, sources, editors, multinationals)
Why not use metadata?
- Re: Why not use metadata?
  - Re: Why not use metadata?
    - Re: Why not use metadata?
    - Re: Why not use metadata?
  - Fwd: Why not use metadata?
Re: How to leverage our enormous list traffic: two proposals
Limit posts per day, migrate most traffic to Web forums?
Good news for us
Semi-OT: Gmane
- Re: Semi-OT: Gmane
Many replies
- Re: Many replies
- Re: Many replies
- Babysitting
  - Re: Babysitting
    - Re: Babies Sitting
    - Re: Babysitting
    - Re: Babysitting
    - Re: Babysitting
    - Re: Babysitting
    - Re: Babyseeing
    - Re: Babyseeing
    - Re: Babyciting
    - Re: Babysitting
    - Re: Babysitting
    - Re: Babysitting
- All-at-once fork - mundane problems
  - Re: mundane solution for Larry maybe
  - Re: All-at-once fork - mundane problems
Wordpress
Citizens' Compendium or Experts' Compendium?
How to leverage our enormous list traffic: two proposals
- Re: How to leverage our enormous list traffic: two proposals
  - Re: How to leverage our enormous list traffic: two proposals
What are experts, again, and how do they work?
Re: Citizendium-l Digest, Vol 1, Issue 22
Will this work?
- Re: Will this work?
- Re: Will this work?
  - Re: Will this work?
- Re: Will this work?
  - Re: Will this work?
    - Re: Will this work?
    - Re: Will this work?
    - Re: Will this work?
  - Re: Will this work?
Fwd from Derek Lyons: Re: The 4 main types of sources
Re: reliability, homonyms, content, sources, editors, multinationals
- Re: reliability, homonyms, content, sources, editors, multinationals
  - MediaWiki skin-ing features (was Re: reliability, homonyms, content, sources, editors, multinationals)
  - Fwd: reliability, homonyms, content, sources, editors, multinationals
Breakpoint 3. Becoming a Resource that Researchers Actually Use
Breakpoint 2. Lack of Acquaintance with the Conversation on Knowledge
On the relative value of references.
A new year, a new encyclopedia (Was: High priority tasks)
- Re: A new year, a new encyclopedia (Was: High priority tasks)
Re: Vote to keep name: YES
- Re: Vote to keep name: YES
- Re: Vote to keep name: YES
Goal of Citizendium
Progressive fork of Wikipedia, editorship and authorship
Must... get... sleep...
- Re: Must... get... sleep...
Editors - the cathedral and the bazaar
- Re: Editors - the cathedral and the bazaar
  - Re: Editors - the cathedral and the bazaar
    - Re: Editors - the cathedral and the bazaar
Breakpoint 1. Anonymity => Irresponsibility => Police => Autocracy
Quality and Openness: LogiLogi, no trade-off needed...
Re: Citizendium-l Digest, Vol 1, Issue 2
- Re: Citizendium-l Digest, Vol 1, Issue 2
  - Re: Citizendium-l Digest, Vol 1, Issue 2
licensing (was: Re: a truly rigorous/accurate resource process design)
- Re: licensing
  - Re: licensing
    - Re: licensing
    - Re: licensing
    - Will this work?
    - Re: Will this work?
    - Re: Will this work?
- Re: licensing (was: Re: a truly rigorous/accurate resource process design)
Re: Citizendium-l Digest, Vol 1, Issue 3
- Re: Citizendium-l Digest, Vol 1, Issue 3
Copyeditors and other proposed changes
Showing only "verified" content
Idea for name competition!!
- Re: Idea for name competition!!
  - Re: Idea for name competition!!
Re: Citizendium-l Digest, Vol 1, Issue 5
Re: a truly rigorous/accurate resource process design
- Re: a truly rigorous/accurate resource process design
- Re: a truly rigorous/accurate resource process design
Thoughts on Real Names, and related issues
Citizendium press contacts?
- Re: Citizendium press contacts?
  - Re: Citizendium press contacts?
WG: Expertise, Editorial quality and Progressive Forking
- reply-to headers (was Re: WG: Expertise, Editorial quality and Progressive Forking)
WG: Basic Questions
WG: [Citizendium-policy] Thoughts on Citizendium
- Re: WG: [Citizendium-policy] Thoughts on Citizendium
- range of subject matters (was Re: WG: Thoughts on Citizendium)
On views, presentation and first impressions
Re: High priority tasks...
- Re: High priority tasks...
Re: Vote to keep name:no
- Re: Vote to keep name:yes
Expertise, Editorial quality and Progressive Forking
- Re: Expertise, Editorial quality and Progressive Forking
  - Re: Expertise, Editorial quality and Progressive Forking
Introductions
Vote to keep name:
- Re: Vote to keep name:
  - Re: Vote to keep name:
    - Re: Vote to keep name:
    - Re: Vote to keep name:
  - Re: Vote to keep name:
    - Re: Vote to keep name:
    - Re: Vote to keep name:
  - Re: Vote to keep name:
- Re: Vote to keep name: No
- Re: Vote to keep name:
  - Re: Vote to keep name:
    - Re: Vote to keep name:
    - Re: Vote to keep name:
    - Re: Vote to keep name:
    - Re: Vote to keep name:
    - Re: Vote to keep name:
    - domain hijacking (was Re: Vote to keep name:)
  - Re: Vote to keep name:
    - Re: Vote to keep name:
Two high-priority volunteer tasks
- Re: Two high-priority volunteer tasks
Basic Questions
- Re: Basic Questions
playing devil's advocate
- Re: playing devil's advocate
On Expertise
Proposal
- Re: [Citizendium-policy] Proposal
  - Experts and fields (Re: [Citizendium-policy] Proposal)
    - Re: Experts and fields (Re: [Citizendium-policy] Proposal)
Count me in
List kick-off
I'm back, hard work begins tomorrow
Interest from Experts?
R: "How open collaboration works: an introduction for scholars"
- Re: R: "How open collaboration works: an introduction for scholars"
Some initial thoughts
Good thing
- Crazy idea
  - Re: Crazy idea
  - Re: Crazy idea
    - Re: Crazy idea
    - Re: Crazy idea
    - Re: Crazy idea
a truly rigorous/accurate resource process design
- Re: a truly rigorous/accurate resource process design
  - The 4 main types of sources (was Re: a truly rigorous/accurate resource process design)
- reference to truthmapping.com
  - Re: reference to truthmapping.com, ClaiMaker
  - Re: reference to truthmapping.com
Call for moderators; also, summarizing list discussions on a wiki
"How open collaboration works: an introduction for scholars"
- Re: "How open collaboration works: an introduction for scholars"
- Re: "How open collaboration works: an introduction for scholars"
  - Re: "How open collaboration works: an introduction for scholars"
Report from the road
- Re: Report from the road
  - Re: Report from the road - GFDL vs. CC-BY-SA
    - Re: Report from the road - GFDL vs. CC-BY-SA
Idea: Highlight editor-reviewed passages with some special color/indicator
- Re: Idea: Highlight editor-reviewed passages with some special color/indicator
  - Re: Idea: Highlight editor-reviewed passages with some special color/indicator
    - Re: Idea: Highlight editor-reviewed passages with some special color/indicator
    - Re: Idea: Highlight editor-reviewed passages with some special color/indicator
Great!

Monthly Indexes

science.linguistics.citizendium.general (thread)