Conspiracy Blame Game
Some things happen by coincidence, or because of human frailty. And there
is no conspiracy and that is the most unsettling answer of all for those
who play the conspiracy blame game.
There are legal conspiracies. And in a major Supreme Court decision in
2003, the high court ruled that a criminal conspiracy does not end simply
because its purpose has been thwarted by the government. Antherwords, if
you plan to carry out a criminal act and do it with others you can be
prosecuted for criminal conspiracy, regardless of whether or not the act
was carried out. Law enforcement now have greater leeway against
_potential_ conspirators, whether as the court said, their purpose is to
carry out a criminal act or to spread terror.
In spite of so many attempts to explain the JFK assassination, the
conspiracy still maintains after over 40 years that John F. Kennedy was
gunned down in Dallas, Texas. Everyone knows the story. No evidence that
it was a conspiracy but the conspiracy lives on. There is no disproving it
that will satisfy those who will continue to believe the MAfia did it, the
CIA did it, the US military did it, the Vice President (Lyndon Johnson)
did it, the Soviets did it, the Cubans did it, and I did it.
There is no evidence that JFK intended to pull the troops out of Vietnam
but some have claimed that as part of the conspiracy.
My son told me about this one, that Neil Armstrong never really walked on
the moon in 1969. The conspiracists say the radiation would have killed
them. But the conspiracists say NASA and the government knew we were
losing the space race with the Soviets and faking Apolo 11 was one way to
get funding and rally the masses behind the project. Instead of going to
the moon, they went to some secret base under the Nevada desert.
There are conspiracies about UFOs. That was really big in the 60s and 70s.
And the bigest conspiracy of all about aliens is why the U.S. government
covered it up. Why would they?
I'm always getting mail about the Illuminati and Bildeberg. This one has
got to be the favorite of those on the interNUT. You see why I call it
that, don't you? And not to forget the Carlyle Group, and it must be a
conspiracy because not only the Bush family is in it, so is bin Laden.
Well, they are but that hardly makes it a conspiracy. Price Bandar is
called "Bandar Bush" by Barbara Bush, but that hardly makes their
association a conspiracy. And not finding the WMD in Iraq hardly makes it
a conspiracy, but Bush went to war over that conspiracy theory.
I'm not going to repeat these ridiculous ideas because you have already
heard them all, but one of the most idiotic is the twenty dollar bill.
If you fold a 20 dollar bill the right way, you can see an image of
the Twin Towers on fire.
For certain, the net is ablaze with fired up surfers who are convinced
that the terrorist attacks on the Twin Towers were part of a conspiracy.
And many believe the Jews did it.
"The terrorist attacks already look set to outstrip the JFK
assassination and the death of Princess Diana as the world's greatest
provoker of conspiracy theories." (Lashmar) *
* (Paul Lashmar, - The Independent Sunday (London, England) - (9/23/2001 -
"AMERICA AT WAR: Conspiracy enthusiasts - Some blame Jews, others Bush.
Everyone has a theory on the Net.")
"Already dozens of different plots have been exposed on the internet.
On the 30,000 or so websites that specialise in conspiracies, the
events of 11 September are referred to as "911": the US shorthand for
that date, and also the country's emergency telephone number."
(Lashmar)
In the Middle East in Muslim countries and anywhere there are Muslim
communities everything can be blamed on Zionists. The term doesn't even
mean what it once did anymore. It is an age old conspiracy to take over
the world and I don't know what they expect the Jews to do to the Muslims,
but since Islamic countries kept losing wars against Israel, it just
fueled the conspiracy even more. It is the Zionists and it is the Mossad.
The left picks up where the right leaves off and that is unfortunate. A
lot of new, young people on the left, need to read Chip Berlet's website
and understand this phenomenon a lot better than I can explain it.
Even the attack itself is being denied by Muslims. They say the Jews did
it. I guess they were all converts to Judaism from Islam and all of them
(15 of these secret Jews) were from Saudi Arabia (where no Jew can live).
One version is the Israeli government "secretly" (that is the conspiracy)
told 4,000 Israelis who work in Manhattan to stay home that day.
(The point that is missed with this theory is that many Israelis died too)
A really novel and incredibly funny theory is the one about the Tarot
cards.
"Among American conspiracy theorists, fingers are pointed at the Bush
administration. One cites the Tarot cards. `The six-pointed star
(Jewry's capital after Jerusalem, New York City) and the five pointed
star (Masonry's military capital, Arlington's five-sided Pentagon)
were show to be symbolically and literally weak on Sept 11.'"
(Lashmar)
"Robin Ramsay, British author of a book on conspiracy theories, says:
`E-mails that are circulating at the moment refer to the WTC attack in
terms of the Reichstag fire. According to this theory the CIA
orchestrated the terrorism so that the Bush administration can
withdraw civil liberties and impose a fascist government. This idea
has taken particular hold with those who believe that Waco and the
Oklahoma bombing were organised by the US government.'"
(ibid)
"The American conspiracy theorist Sherman Skolnick declared the US
government knew about the attacks. `The CIA also was informed prior to
the `terrorist' attacks, scheduled for `911' Emergency Day, that
highly skilled Iraqi pilots were among the four thousand Iraqi
officers resident in the US.'" (ibid)
"The Konformist, an American conspiracy site, says the evidence of a
fundamentalist Arab involvement in the attacks is just a little too
pat. `On Saturday, just days after the attack, they announced that in
the rubble of the trade center they found one of the terrorist's
passports. We all saw that fireball! The fire was so hot it turned the
steel of the building into hot liquid molten metal. But his passport
survived? And it was found even though they had only gone through
20,000 tons of debris out of a total of 1.4 million tons? It's like
reaching out and taking a pinch from the haystack and lo and behold!
There's the needle.'" (ibid)
<snip>
"There are also endless rumours of prior knowledge. According to one, a
US Navy serviceman stationed on an aircraft carrier called his family
in America well before the crashes, alerting them that something big
`was about to go down in a major urban area'." (ibid)
<snip>
"Perhaps the most unhinged of all the theories is the idea that the
Swiss did it. According to this one, there was a meeting of the Bank
of International Settlements on the day of the attack. "The BIS is
known as the Bank of the world's central bankers." The idea was that
it would raise the price of gold, in which the Swiss have large
holdings, to strengthen the already strong Swiss position when it
joins(ed) the euro later this year." (ibid)
Hank Roth
http://pnews.org/
---
/ o o \
===OO=====OO=================================================
http://pnews.org/vortal/ New World disOrder and Myth Busters
http://g0lem.net/vortal/ Insane Planet and Wacko World
http://g0lem.net/portal/ Bad-Ass Truth and TheGolemsPortal
http://pnews.org/portal/ Naked Truth and PNEWS Portal
http://g0lem.net/PhpWiki/ (Wiki)
http://pnews.org/ (Home)
-DON'T FEED THE TROLLS-
=============================================================
\_/ \_/
Thread at a glance:
Previous Message by Date:
click to view message preview
Avoidance and Conspiracy Theorists
Avoidance and Conspiracy Theorists
Just like my commentary about Wikis not being created equal neither are
conspiracy theories. Conspiracies have a twisted appeal to just about
everyone because no one can know everything but when you tie all the
coincidences together you can see how conspiracies become the glue that
connects the dots. It connects the coincidences together.
Paxdora thinks I took down her Wiki comments about conspiracism because
she believes in them and I don't, but nothing could be further from the
truth, and it isn't a conspiracy Paxdora that caused your links to
destruct and any paranoia you might have about the removal of your remarks
are not without reason and it was not done intentionally because I didn't
like what you said. Folks who know me here know I have not censored their
views, even when they disagreed with mine (But I do want people who use my
servers to follow basic rules).
To make your conspiracy work you have to believe I did it because I do not
agree with you. That part you can take to the bank. That is, I do not
agree with you. But that is not the reason you have had your access denied
and some of your pages removed.
Paxdora, you don't read. At least twice you removed comments above the
line. The instructions were simple. It said, "Do not remove or alter
comments above" and you did it anyway. You didn't just do it once. You did
it twice and you reverted page more than twice. usually twice is enough.
And why or how you deleted your internal links I still haven't figured
out.
Of course there are some real conspiracies. Otherwise we would not have
laws against combinations and anti-trust laws against collective decisions
to control prices. And we know the Jews control Hollywood and the media.
Just ask anyone. We know the Freemasons are Jewish power brokers, and we
know the Pope tells Catholic presidents what to do. We know that Ike was
a communist. Ask the John Birchers.
See http://g0lem.net/PhpWiki/CriticismOfConspiracism
and the links there for some very good articles about conspiracies.
There is a real twisted appeal to all manner of conspiracies. America
needs it's conspiracies. The LEFT does not. The Right needs Waco, Ruby
Ridge, the CIA crack connection, the death of Clinton aide, Vince Foster
(who it was finally admitted from the investigation that it was a suicide)
and the X-files. And not to forget Area 51 and JFK, and we never walked on
the moon. My son saw that one on television (I think they made a movie)
and he said, "Hey dad, did you know we never went to the moon?"
The lawyer for Timothy McVeigh tried to sell an elaborate conspiracy how
the bombing in Oklahoma City was orchestrated by foreign terrorists.
Of course it was Tim McVeigh, not al-Qaeda but there were many who wanted
to believe his attorney.
Some people, like Paxdora, do not even realize they're being manipulated.
And in spite of the denial that they do, conspiracy theories do serve
political agendas. It serves the right's purpose to have everyone believe
that a very sinister few people are masterminding everything in order to
rule the world.
One of the best books I read about this paranoia was historian Richard
Hofstadter's "Paranoid Style in American Politics," written many years ago
and still relevant. Lately there have been a spate of new books debunking
conspiracies. I have read reviews of several of them. Some are from a few
authors, who while brilliant and very insightful, are not well considered
by the left because they are too supportive of Israel. It is too bad
because Pipes is a masterful writer and very informed. But he isn't the
only one writing about conspiracism and very critical of conspiracies and
those who promote them. Almost the entire Middle-East problem between
Islam and the West is based on acceptance of false conspiracies spoon-fed
to Muslims by their clerics and rulers.
Chip Berlet, who is a left wing activist and journalist, is the leading
critic and an exceptional writer ON THE LEFT who wrote "Right Woos Left"
and other critiques which if you haven't read, you should do so. See
http://publiceye.com/
Why are Americans especially so paranoid? I had the great fortune and
privilege to work in the White House. I consider it an honor that I did
and have no regrets because the president at the time was Ike and _I Like
Ike_.. Remember that phrase? Maybe you don't, but there were buttons made
which said that and my mother liked him and he was a good person to work
for. When I worked in the War Room, it was not as pleasurable but it was
my lot in life to be chosen to be in those places. I'd like to say it was
because of my intellect, but I think it was more because I was the ideal
candidate when chosen for that job; I did very good on all my exams and
ham radio was my hobby since I 14. And I had finished 3 years in a
military school so I was the ideal patriotic military type. Anyway I can
tell you there were no conspiracies in those high towers of government.
None. I heard all the conversations because that was part of my job. I was
the voice-security expert and that is what I did. Conspiracy was just
something others said about what was being done - but unless I was missing
something very basic, it was all business of running the country and a few
people were in charge. They didn't receive subliminal messages nor real
calls over the phone or radio nor on the crypto machines to tell them what
to do.
These Right-Wing talk show hosts talk conspiracy BS everyday. Have you
ever turned them on? Of course you have. Everyone does. Some are fixated
on what they say, as if they have the real inside scoop on what is
happening. Free speech is a wonderful thing, but that aside, these right
wing nuts, with an audience, do a lot of harm.
And we are in a sorry state of affairs when a majority of the population
of America feels threatened. It doesn't help when the office of Home Land
Defense keeps issuing warnings that we are being attacked. Maybe there are
threats but wouldn't you rather they took care of it without telling us
all the time, when there isn't a damn thing we could do anyway because
we're not the ones who would do anything. If anything someone may load
their guns and have an itchy trigger finger next time the teenage kids
come home late.
The Bush administration does not help, because "yelling wolf" so many
times does more to fuel the paranoia than anything and you know Bush W. is
a conspiracist. He believes in Armageddon and if that isn't conspiracy
theory, I don't know the meaning of the term.
And there have been real cover-ups and the FBI has spied on many radical
and other domestic peace and justice, anti-establishment organizations. We
all remember COINTELPRO. That was real. Vietnam veterans were spied on.
Is that a conspiracy or the government's business as usual? I say it is
the way they do business and that is the way we MUST look at it. The CIA
gets down in the gutter, just like cops everywhere and they do things
which are not what you expect. They work with informers who are gutter
scum and some say those are conspiracies. Any sting is a conspiracy.
It is a cover-up and we have the mechanism to deal with it.
There are many instances of the misuse of power. The constitution
guarantees rights but they often have to be fought for. That is the
purpose of the left.
About 400 African-Americans (men) with syphilis were untreated for 40
years as part of the Tuskegee study and the government never apologized
until just recently. That was a conspiracy of silence because it covered
up the real facts of the wrong-doing.
The problem with criticizing critics of conspiracism while considering
wrong-doing conspiracies, when they are the natural way of governments
doing their business to protect wealth is misleading and diversionary for
the left which must oppose power and privilege which leads to this coverup
and wrong-doing in the first place.
It is much easier for the Right to adopt conspiracies about everything and
play the blame game. They do that by blaming Jews, African-Americans,
Immigrants and all those people who are as much the victims of skewed
policies as those on the right are. The first objective is always to SEEK
THE TRUTH. And then Seek Justice ("dirshu mishpat").
Here is why conspiricies do more harm than they explain anything:
Conspiracymongers cause it to be difficult for those of us who are seeking
the truth. Conspiracists play the blame game. They damage credibility of
government institutions. They raise the level of cynicism.
The exposes which have appears in the mainstream media has in many
instances been flawed in their endeavor to make the case for blame.
Fair and balanced is not something you find much of in the news nor
especially, not on the interNUT.
I remember how the left said, "We told you" so when the journalist in the
San Jose Mercury News reported that there had been an undeniable
connection to the spread of crack in the inner cities and the CIA's
involvement. You all remember that, right? But it was afterwards that the
San Jose Mercury News admitted that that those articles which it had
reported and were picked up by everyone, from left to right and repeated
everywhere, as it usually is on the net; well, they were SIGNIFICANTLY
FLAWED, so said the San Jose Mercury News.
Do you know how many letters I get all the time about my essays on the
U.S.S. Liberty, how it was "friendly fire" and not intentional at all.
And tapes have even been released (just recently) which attest to that
fact, and it is still disbelieved because these same people, mostly on the
right, but also on the left, WANT (no NEED) to blame the Israelis.
Nothing quite diminishes the appeal of these outlandish conspiracy
theories. Why is that? They fill a primary need to play the blame game.
Paxdora needs to play the blame game. She is a pansien. She believes in
many gods and I don't mean to belittle her belief structure, but come on
--- belief in many is safer than belief in one. AND belief in conspiracy
is safe because it is some kind of answer, even if it is the wrong one.
Even if it is wrong. As I hope I have said before, believing in
conspiracies really does fill an urgent need for people to AVOID admitting
the most obvious answers of them all, that SHIT HAPPENS!
Hank Roth
http://pnews.org/
---
/ o o \
===OO=====OO=================================================
http://pnews.org/vortal/ New World disOrder and Myth Busters
http://g0lem.net/vortal/ Insane Planet and Wacko World
http://g0lem.net/portal/ Bad-Ass Truth and TheGolemsPortal
http://pnews.org/portal/ Naked Truth and PNEWS Portal
http://g0lem.net/PhpWiki/ (Wiki) http://pnews.org/ (Home)
-DON'T FEED THE TROLLS-
=============================================================
\_/ \_/
Next Message by Date:
click to view message preview
Conspiracy Mania
As I was walking up the stair,
I met a man who wasn't there.
He wasn't there again today.
I wish, I wish he'd go away
--Author unknown
The Cancer of Conspiracism Has Begun to Metastasize
Conspiracy Mania
There isn't much that goes on anywhere that isn't part of some huge
conspiracy. That is how Americans believe. I couldn't believe the
statistics I heard recently about how so many in America believe in
Evangelical Christianity. It was a huge figure and over 90 percentile
believed in God. And it was almost 50 percent that were Evangelicals. That
is some really committed faith. You have to have it because it is a
literal interpretation of everything said in the Bible. No wonder Mel
Gibson's "The Passion" was such a sell-out everywhere it played.
Distrust of government is healthy but conspiracies have caused Americans
to cross over into the dark zone - and they now have a neurotic distrust
of everything. It has become more than simply a "secret collaboration"
between two or more people for some evil and wicked end result. It is how
conspiracists explain all insufficiently explicable phenomenon and the
more complicated society becomes the more it is considered a conspiracy.
Here is what Robert Alan Goldberg in "Enemies Within: The Culture of
Conspiracy in Modern America" (2002 from Yale U Press) says about the
culture of conspiracy. He explains: "conspiracism is an American
tradition. Yet there is danger in the observance. Conspiracism demonizes
opponents and makes struggle internecine. Victories in such conflicts can
only be Pyrrhic. Conspiracy thinking has moved Americans beyond a healthy
skepticism of authority. Lacking public confidence, core institutions
become unstable and lose their ability to govern. The cancer of
conspiracism has begun to metastasize. Without a new awareness of its
character and quick intervention, countersubversion may overcome the body
politic."
Conspiracists are the fringe of both the left and the right. And lately
there isn't much difference between the two for their same theories and
the blame game they play.
There are some semantic differences when you define conspiracy where there
is the most disagreement and interpretations vary.
For example where the San Jose Mercury News story tried to show a
connection between the CIA and drugs there was no conspiracy to flood the
Black community with drugs, whereas the story did imply the connection
would ultimately have that effect. The story never reached the conclusion
that the CIA was involved in a conspiracy. What the story did was provide
circumstantial evidence to a link between the CIA and the Contras. There
was no conspiracy because there was NO "secret agreement" to do an
unlawful or wrongful act. There was no conspiracy to flood the Black
community with drugs.
BUT as can be seen by the kernel of truth in that story, like most
conspiracy theories, they contain a small element of truth. While world
government is the objective of some according to the conspiracists, it is
not a theory that many people would object to if the government is to
their liking. I remember back in the 50s we use to talk about how much
better it would be to have one world, one government. That was a popular
idea or of a League of Nations (and then the United Nations) would not
have gotten off the ground. That is because many people do favor world
government.
National Paranoia
In Hofstadter, he states in his book that one ingredient of conspiracy was
the idea of a government that controlled the economy. There was the
intention of central planning but it was not a conspiracy and since WWII
leverage of foreign aid through the World Bank and IMF has encouraged
central planning in the Third World. There is no "secret" deal to make it
so.
Tom Bethell in National Review (8-28-95) writes:
"...Take the business of a conspiracy to achieve world government -- an
abiding element of conspiracy theorizing, endorsed by today's militiamen.
The goal of world government is considered ridiculous by some of the very
people who spent their lives dreaming about it. They advocated it, and
invested a fair amount of energy in the idea. But once they heard they
were ``conspiring'' to attain it, their ridicule of the non-existent plot
also conveniently dissociated them from the goal and made the idea of
world government itself seem silly...."
There is an organization called the World Federalists. Some call it
conspiracy. The president use to be actor Sir Peter Ustinov and it was
a bit of a joke to some people, but the idea may yet catch on.
Ustinov said (paraphrased by Bethell):
"The planet will come to its senses, wars will cease, nations will buddy
up and a new international court will convict the ringleaders in Bosnia
for the ``repellent and stupid'' evil of ethnic cleansing."
The European Union is likely a step in that direction. This is not a time
for George W. Bush to be pissing off the allies we desperately need in our
quest for world peace.
Hank Roth
http://pnews.org/
AND, IMO, a one world government (one people) is not such a bad idea
either.
---
/ o o \
===OO=====OO=================================================
http://pnews.org/vortal/ New World disOrder and Myth Busters
http://g0lem.net/vortal/ Insane Planet and Wacko World
http://g0lem.net/portal/ Bad-Ass Truth and TheGolemsPortal
http://pnews.org/portal/ Naked Truth and PNEWS Portal
http://g0lem.net/PhpWiki/ (Wiki) http://pnews.org/ (Home)
-DON'T FEED THE TROLLS-
=============================================================
\_/ \_/
Previous Message by Thread:
click to view message preview
Avoidance and Conspiracy Theorists
Avoidance and Conspiracy Theorists
Just like my commentary about Wikis not being created equal neither are
conspiracy theories. Conspiracies have a twisted appeal to just about
everyone because no one can know everything but when you tie all the
coincidences together you can see how conspiracies become the glue that
connects the dots. It connects the coincidences together.
Paxdora thinks I took down her Wiki comments about conspiracism because
she believes in them and I don't, but nothing could be further from the
truth, and it isn't a conspiracy Paxdora that caused your links to
destruct and any paranoia you might have about the removal of your remarks
are not without reason and it was not done intentionally because I didn't
like what you said. Folks who know me here know I have not censored their
views, even when they disagreed with mine (But I do want people who use my
servers to follow basic rules).
To make your conspiracy work you have to believe I did it because I do not
agree with you. That part you can take to the bank. That is, I do not
agree with you. But that is not the reason you have had your access denied
and some of your pages removed.
Paxdora, you don't read. At least twice you removed comments above the
line. The instructions were simple. It said, "Do not remove or alter
comments above" and you did it anyway. You didn't just do it once. You did
it twice and you reverted page more than twice. usually twice is enough.
And why or how you deleted your internal links I still haven't figured
out.
Of course there are some real conspiracies. Otherwise we would not have
laws against combinations and anti-trust laws against collective decisions
to control prices. And we know the Jews control Hollywood and the media.
Just ask anyone. We know the Freemasons are Jewish power brokers, and we
know the Pope tells Catholic presidents what to do. We know that Ike was
a communist. Ask the John Birchers.
See http://g0lem.net/PhpWiki/CriticismOfConspiracism
and the links there for some very good articles about conspiracies.
There is a real twisted appeal to all manner of conspiracies. America
needs it's conspiracies. The LEFT does not. The Right needs Waco, Ruby
Ridge, the CIA crack connection, the death of Clinton aide, Vince Foster
(who it was finally admitted from the investigation that it was a suicide)
and the X-files. And not to forget Area 51 and JFK, and we never walked on
the moon. My son saw that one on television (I think they made a movie)
and he said, "Hey dad, did you know we never went to the moon?"
The lawyer for Timothy McVeigh tried to sell an elaborate conspiracy how
the bombing in Oklahoma City was orchestrated by foreign terrorists.
Of course it was Tim McVeigh, not al-Qaeda but there were many who wanted
to believe his attorney.
Some people, like Paxdora, do not even realize they're being manipulated.
And in spite of the denial that they do, conspiracy theories do serve
political agendas. It serves the right's purpose to have everyone believe
that a very sinister few people are masterminding everything in order to
rule the world.
One of the best books I read about this paranoia was historian Richard
Hofstadter's "Paranoid Style in American Politics," written many years ago
and still relevant. Lately there have been a spate of new books debunking
conspiracies. I have read reviews of several of them. Some are from a few
authors, who while brilliant and very insightful, are not well considered
by the left because they are too supportive of Israel. It is too bad
because Pipes is a masterful writer and very informed. But he isn't the
only one writing about conspiracism and very critical of conspiracies and
those who promote them. Almost the entire Middle-East problem between
Islam and the West is based on acceptance of false conspiracies spoon-fed
to Muslims by their clerics and rulers.
Chip Berlet, who is a left wing activist and journalist, is the leading
critic and an exceptional writer ON THE LEFT who wrote "Right Woos Left"
and other critiques which if you haven't read, you should do so. See
http://publiceye.com/
Why are Americans especially so paranoid? I had the great fortune and
privilege to work in the White House. I consider it an honor that I did
and have no regrets because the president at the time was Ike and _I Like
Ike_.. Remember that phrase? Maybe you don't, but there were buttons made
which said that and my mother liked him and he was a good person to work
for. When I worked in the War Room, it was not as pleasurable but it was
my lot in life to be chosen to be in those places. I'd like to say it was
because of my intellect, but I think it was more because I was the ideal
candidate when chosen for that job; I did very good on all my exams and
ham radio was my hobby since I 14. And I had finished 3 years in a
military school so I was the ideal patriotic military type. Anyway I can
tell you there were no conspiracies in those high towers of government.
None. I heard all the conversations because that was part of my job. I was
the voice-security expert and that is what I did. Conspiracy was just
something others said about what was being done - but unless I was missing
something very basic, it was all business of running the country and a few
people were in charge. They didn't receive subliminal messages nor real
calls over the phone or radio nor on the crypto machines to tell them what
to do.
These Right-Wing talk show hosts talk conspiracy BS everyday. Have you
ever turned them on? Of course you have. Everyone does. Some are fixated
on what they say, as if they have the real inside scoop on what is
happening. Free speech is a wonderful thing, but that aside, these right
wing nuts, with an audience, do a lot of harm.
And we are in a sorry state of affairs when a majority of the population
of America feels threatened. It doesn't help when the office of Home Land
Defense keeps issuing warnings that we are being attacked. Maybe there are
threats but wouldn't you rather they took care of it without telling us
all the time, when there isn't a damn thing we could do anyway because
we're not the ones who would do anything. If anything someone may load
their guns and have an itchy trigger finger next time the teenage kids
come home late.
The Bush administration does not help, because "yelling wolf" so many
times does more to fuel the paranoia than anything and you know Bush W. is
a conspiracist. He believes in Armageddon and if that isn't conspiracy
theory, I don't know the meaning of the term.
And there have been real cover-ups and the FBI has spied on many radical
and other domestic peace and justice, anti-establishment organizations. We
all remember COINTELPRO. That was real. Vietnam veterans were spied on.
Is that a conspiracy or the government's business as usual? I say it is
the way they do business and that is the way we MUST look at it. The CIA
gets down in the gutter, just like cops everywhere and they do things
which are not what you expect. They work with informers who are gutter
scum and some say those are conspiracies. Any sting is a conspiracy.
It is a cover-up and we have the mechanism to deal with it.
There are many instances of the misuse of power. The constitution
guarantees rights but they often have to be fought for. That is the
purpose of the left.
About 400 African-Americans (men) with syphilis were untreated for 40
years as part of the Tuskegee study and the government never apologized
until just recently. That was a conspiracy of silence because it covered
up the real facts of the wrong-doing.
The problem with criticizing critics of conspiracism while considering
wrong-doing conspiracies, when they are the natural way of governments
doing their business to protect wealth is misleading and diversionary for
the left which must oppose power and privilege which leads to this coverup
and wrong-doing in the first place.
It is much easier for the Right to adopt conspiracies about everything and
play the blame game. They do that by blaming Jews, African-Americans,
Immigrants and all those people who are as much the victims of skewed
policies as those on the right are. The first objective is always to SEEK
THE TRUTH. And then Seek Justice ("dirshu mishpat").
Here is why conspiricies do more harm than they explain anything:
Conspiracymongers cause it to be difficult for those of us who are seeking
the truth. Conspiracists play the blame game. They damage credibility of
government institutions. They raise the level of cynicism.
The exposes which have appears in the mainstream media has in many
instances been flawed in their endeavor to make the case for blame.
Fair and balanced is not something you find much of in the news nor
especially, not on the interNUT.
I remember how the left said, "We told you" so when the journalist in the
San Jose Mercury News reported that there had been an undeniable
connection to the spread of crack in the inner cities and the CIA's
involvement. You all remember that, right? But it was afterwards that the
San Jose Mercury News admitted that that those articles which it had
reported and were picked up by everyone, from left to right and repeated
everywhere, as it usually is on the net; well, they were SIGNIFICANTLY
FLAWED, so said the San Jose Mercury News.
Do you know how many letters I get all the time about my essays on the
U.S.S. Liberty, how it was "friendly fire" and not intentional at all.
And tapes have even been released (just recently) which attest to that
fact, and it is still disbelieved because these same people, mostly on the
right, but also on the left, WANT (no NEED) to blame the Israelis.
Nothing quite diminishes the appeal of these outlandish conspiracy
theories. Why is that? They fill a primary need to play the blame game.
Paxdora needs to play the blame game. She is a pansien. She believes in
many gods and I don't mean to belittle her belief structure, but come on
--- belief in many is safer than belief in one. AND belief in conspiracy
is safe because it is some kind of answer, even if it is the wrong one.
Even if it is wrong. As I hope I have said before, believing in
conspiracies really does fill an urgent need for people to AVOID admitting
the most obvious answers of them all, that SHIT HAPPENS!
Hank Roth
http://pnews.org/
---
/ o o \
===OO=====OO=================================================
http://pnews.org/vortal/ New World disOrder and Myth Busters
http://g0lem.net/vortal/ Insane Planet and Wacko World
http://g0lem.net/portal/ Bad-Ass Truth and TheGolemsPortal
http://pnews.org/portal/ Naked Truth and PNEWS Portal
http://g0lem.net/PhpWiki/ (Wiki) http://pnews.org/ (Home)
-DON'T FEED THE TROLLS-
=============================================================
\_/ \_/
Next Message by Thread:
click to view message preview
Conspiracy Mania
As I was walking up the stair,
I met a man who wasn't there.
He wasn't there again today.
I wish, I wish he'd go away
--Author unknown
The Cancer of Conspiracism Has Begun to Metastasize
Conspiracy Mania
There isn't much that goes on anywhere that isn't part of some huge
conspiracy. That is how Americans believe. I couldn't believe the
statistics I heard recently about how so many in America believe in
Evangelical Christianity. It was a huge figure and over 90 percentile
believed in God. And it was almost 50 percent that were Evangelicals. That
is some really committed faith. You have to have it because it is a
literal interpretation of everything said in the Bible. No wonder Mel
Gibson's "The Passion" was such a sell-out everywhere it played.
Distrust of government is healthy but conspiracies have caused Americans
to cross over into the dark zone - and they now have a neurotic distrust
of everything. It has become more than simply a "secret collaboration"
between two or more people for some evil and wicked end result. It is how
conspiracists explain all insufficiently explicable phenomenon and the
more complicated society becomes the more it is considered a conspiracy.
Here is what Robert Alan Goldberg in "Enemies Within: The Culture of
Conspiracy in Modern America" (2002 from Yale U Press) says about the
culture of conspiracy. He explains: "conspiracism is an American
tradition. Yet there is danger in the observance. Conspiracism demonizes
opponents and makes struggle internecine. Victories in such conflicts can
only be Pyrrhic. Conspiracy thinking has moved Americans beyond a healthy
skepticism of authority. Lacking public confidence, core institutions
become unstable and lose their ability to govern. The cancer of
conspiracism has begun to metastasize. Without a new awareness of its
character and quick intervention, countersubversion may overcome the body
politic."
Conspiracists are the fringe of both the left and the right. And lately
there isn't much difference between the two for their same theories and
the blame game they play.
There are some semantic differences when you define conspiracy where there
is the most disagreement and interpretations vary.
For example where the San Jose Mercury News story tried to show a
connection between the CIA and drugs there was no conspiracy to flood the
Black community with drugs, whereas the story did imply the connection
would ultimately have that effect. The story never reached the conclusion
that the CIA was involved in a conspiracy. What the story did was provide
circumstantial evidence to a link between the CIA and the Contras. There
was no conspiracy because there was NO "secret agreement" to do an
unlawful or wrongful act. There was no conspiracy to flood the Black
community with drugs.
BUT as can be seen by the kernel of truth in that story, like most
conspiracy theories, they contain a small element of truth. While world
government is the objective of some according to the conspiracists, it is
not a theory that many people would object to if the government is to
their liking. I remember back in the 50s we use to talk about how much
better it would be to have one world, one government. That was a popular
idea or of a League of Nations (and then the United Nations) would not
have gotten off the ground. That is because many people do favor world
government.
National Paranoia
In Hofstadter, he states in his book that one ingredient of conspiracy was
the idea of a government that controlled the economy. There was the
intention of central planning but it was not a conspiracy and since WWII
leverage of foreign aid through the World Bank and IMF has encouraged
central planning in the Third World. There is no "secret" deal to make it
so.
Tom Bethell in National Review (8-28-95) writes:
"...Take the business of a conspiracy to achieve world government -- an
abiding element of conspiracy theorizing, endorsed by today's militiamen.
The goal of world government is considered ridiculous by some of the very
people who spent their lives dreaming about it. They advocated it, and
invested a fair amount of energy in the idea. But once they heard they
were ``conspiring'' to attain it, their ridicule of the non-existent plot
also conveniently dissociated them from the goal and made the idea of
world government itself seem silly...."
There is an organization called the World Federalists. Some call it
conspiracy. The president use to be actor Sir Peter Ustinov and it was
a bit of a joke to some people, but the idea may yet catch on.
Ustinov said (paraphrased by Bethell):
"The planet will come to its senses, wars will cease, nations will buddy
up and a new international court will convict the ringleaders in Bosnia
for the ``repellent and stupid'' evil of ethnic cleansing."
The European Union is likely a step in that direction. This is not a time
for George W. Bush to be pissing off the allies we desperately need in our
quest for world peace.
Hank Roth
http://pnews.org/
AND, IMO, a one world government (one people) is not such a bad idea
either.
---
/ o o \
===OO=====OO=================================================
http://pnews.org/vortal/ New World disOrder and Myth Busters
http://g0lem.net/vortal/ Insane Planet and Wacko World
http://g0lem.net/portal/ Bad-Ass Truth and TheGolemsPortal
http://pnews.org/portal/ Naked Truth and PNEWS Portal
http://g0lem.net/PhpWiki/ (Wiki) http://pnews.org/ (Home)
-DON'T FEED THE TROLLS-
=============================================================
\_/ \_/