logo       

Re: Potential new issue: PSVI considered harmful: msg#00099

org.w3c.tag

Subject: Re: Potential new issue: PSVI considered harmful


Simon St.Laurent wrote:

4. Work on XQuery and other things that require a Type-Augmented Infoset must not depend on schema processing, and should not have normative linkages to any schema language specifications.

I'd say this item is a crucial requirement if the W3C wants to avoid a serious fork in XML development. Efforts to impose the PSVI as part of the XML core are not very welcome in a lot of places.

On further consideration, I probably would back off my statement above; for example, it seems just fine to refer to the XMl schema basic type repertoire (or hopefully, a subset of it) by reference. The problem that worries me here is where typing information comes from, and the supposition that types exist only as a side-effect of validation processing. -Tim




<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
Google Custom Search

News | FAQ | advertise