Re: [osol-discuss] OpenSolaris graphics performance in Java 2D Microbenchmark beats Linux!!!

A few days ago, I upgraded one of my PCs at home to an AMD Quad, and I have 
noticed a similar surprise in performance differences between OpenSolaris and 
various Linux distros.  (I have no intent of going back to OpenSolaris at least 
for a while; the reason I did this was because I was unable to install Ubuntu 
Jaunty from an external CD drive and a 2009.06 LiveCD happened to be nearby.)

Of course, I am talking about a totally different issue here--this was about 
the (reputedly superior) scalability of Solaris as a whole rather than about a 
particular video driver.  (And I am very curious as to how Solaris benchmarks 
against RedHat on the new six-core AMD Istanbul--or SunFire X4640.)  

However, getting back to the original thread, the inability of Linux to allow 
proprietary drivers to be included in the kernel can IMO create great 
inconveniences.

As I am sure many here are aware, nowadays, chipsets are so complex that they, 
just like today's software code, will, unfortunately and inenvitably, contain 
bugs, many of them not yet identified.  

As a common practice, drivers are written by chipset designers deliberatly to 
circumvent those bugs (which typically will not be published).  When some of 
those bugs are identified and removed, drivers written strictly according to 
the specs may no longer work.  This may explain why Ubuntu Remix, which works 
flawlessly on the Acer Aspire One netbooks, suddenly has no wi-fi on the newest 
models although supposedly the same Atheros chipset is used.

This leads me to a much bigger issue.

Chairman Larry made a big fuss that he wanted to see an alternative to Android 
on netbooks.  I have not seen many discussions on this.  However, for pretty 
much the same reason as I mentioned above, Android may go the same way as Linux 
did--no netbook manufacturers now are taking it seriously.  Perhaps Chairman 
Larry's idea should be given a serious thought--perhaps an authentic Java plus 
a scaled-down OpenSolaris should be the way to go?

We are not talking about just the netbook market (which is expected to reach 30 
million units this year), but also AMD's upcoming traditional notebooks which 
are thin, light-weight, and low-power-consumption, and will cost not much more 
than the netbooks.
-- 
This message posted from opensolaris.org
_______________________________________________
opensolaris-discuss mailing list
opensolaris-discuss@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx