logo       

Re: Tagging issues between Itunes and Slimserver DB's: msg#00283

music.equipment.slimdevices.ripping

Subject: Re: Tagging issues between Itunes and Slimserver DB's

>3. I have always tagged multiple artists using a ";" delimiter in one ARTIST
>tag (and likewise for ARTISTSORT). As this doesn't look good in other
>software, I thought I'd try changing to use multiple ARTIST/ARTISTSORT tags
>(I'm assuming that if the two pairs of tags are entered in the same order, the
>ARTIST/ARTISTSORT relationship will still work correctly). However, I tried
>this with one track and rescanned, and slimserver only displays the first
>artist tag now. The track also has an ALBUMARTIST tag, so could this be
>confusing it? I did a search in the forum for multiple artists, and I see
>that other people have got this working. Before I change all my tags, are
>there any gotcha's? Does other software generally cope with multiple artist
>tags?

A followup to this. I tried it on an album that has the same two artists for
every track, so I didn't need an ALBUMARTIST tag.

I use mp3tag. The album used to be tagged with:
ARTIST=Djivan Gasparayan;Michael Brook
ARTISTSORT=Gasparayan, Djivan;Brook, Michael

I changed this to:
ARTIST=Michael Brook\\Djivan Gasparayan
ARTISTSORT=Brook, Michael\\Gasparayan, Djivan

mp3tag interprets the "\\" as a multiple-tag separator, and actually stores two
artist/artistsort tags. If I look at the list of tags, it lists them as:
ARTIST=Djivan Gasparayan
ARTIST=Michael Brook
ARTISTSORT=Brook, Michael
ARTISTSORT=Gasparayan, Djivan

Interestingly, it has ordered the list of tags, so now the individual artist
and artistsort tags are not matching, but I believe the tags are stored in the
file in the correct order. Foobar displays the two artists and two artist sort
tags correctly.

I revisited the album in slimserver via Browse Music Folder, and only Michael
Brook is displayed for the artist.

I am using slimserver 6.5.1, WinXP Pro.

Phil


<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>
Google Custom Search

News | FAQ | advertise