|
Regressions in new UI: msg#00028gnome.apps.deskbar-applet
Hi all! I'm testing out the new deskbar-applet in Gutsy Gibbon and I must admit that it is quite a bumpy ride :-) Sebastian, please do not take this as a critique of your work, I really like what you are doing, and I can appreciate that it is hard and tricky work :-) Here's a list of regressions that I spotted on the first go: FUNCTIONALITY REGRESSIONS * Does not scale to view all results if window is to small * Hits pane partially obscured on first view * Invalidated a whole slew of 3rd party handlers without warning - do you realize how many are out there? I strongly suggest creating a LegacyModuleLoader or something so old handlers work without modification. And this should be done really soon. NAVIGATIONAL REGRESSIONS I consider these serious because we have a very big user base that will have a forced change of habits, that I assure you will be frustrating to many people. Changing the default navigational patterns should not be taken lightly. * Does not hide on Esc * Type search, hit down-arrow does not focus results * Does not go to top if hit down on bottom hit * Does not go to bottom hit if hitting up on from search entry. * Not closing result window after match selection. IDEAS * History view - how about only displaying either history or the search results? Just show history when the applet is shown without a search string (it should have a visible "History" label somewhere to not confuse people). The mantra should be: "As little in the UI as possible, but shortest route to funtionality". Cheers, Mikkel |
|
| <Prev in Thread] | Current Thread | [Next in Thread> |
|---|---|---|
| Previous by Date: | Re: Deskbar-Applet 2.19.6 released: 00028, Sebastian Pölsterl |
|---|---|
| Next by Date: | Re: Regressions in new UI: 00028, Sebastian Pölsterl |
| Previous by Thread: | Deskbar-Applet 2.19.6.1 releasedi: 00028, Sebastian Pölsterl |
| Next by Thread: | Re: Regressions in new UI: 00028, Sebastian Pölsterl |
| Indexes: | [Date] [Thread] [Top] [All Lists] |
| News | FAQ | advertise |