Re: His Dark Materials (was Re: "Da Vinci" Debunking

> While you could, I suppose, maintain your other criticisms, I can't see how
> you could maintain charges that the books are "unspiritual" if you had
> finished them.  The ending of the third book is very spiritual.

Something about the Democracy of Heaven or something, wasn't it?

> I also don't see how the books are in any way a response to Lewis' Narnia
> books, unless you pulled that name out for rhetorical effect.  The tropes in
> Pullman's books do not related to those of Narnia.  Other than the fact that
> the two books are popular children's fantasies, I see no connection.

The connection is that children travel into other worlds and deal with 
explicitly
religious figures. I think you are probably correct that Pullman wasn't
deliberately writing in response to C.S. Lewis... although Lewis also wrote an
uncompleted story about an 'alternate reality' Oxford (The Dark Tower).

David




__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Win a $20,000 Career Makeover at Yahoo! HotJobs
http://hotjobs.sweepstakes.yahoo.com/careermakeover