Re: transactions from PHP - double COMMIT required?

If you are using PHP5 (and the PDO PGSQL) I would suggest you use exceptions to trap the error

try {

 $db->beginTransaction();

 // other queries here, if one fails, an exception is thrown

 $db->commit();
}
catch (Exception $e) {

 // do whatever with error
 $db->rollback(); 
}

On 3/1/07, mikie < mikie.pl@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

2007/3/1, Mihail Mihailov < Mihail.Mihailov@xxxxxx>:

Hi,

I think you should use ROLLBACK if the query cannot be executed.
one can commit only results of the queries that work.
Try ROLLBACK statement.

The thing is that when I try my transaction from psql console then the command ROLLBACK is being issued by the postgres server itself right after I close my transaction with COMMIT;. According to transaction logic and idea - if something goes wrong then the entire transaction is being cancelled by ROLLBACK - it is the server responsibility to rollback such transaction.

Now, when I try to do some inserts within my transaction I don't know if they will fail or not. Eitherway I am closing my transaction with the COMMIT; command - is that correct way ?
It works logically OK from within psql console (I start with BEGIN and then close my sql commands with commit) but it does not work this way from within PHP script. I believe there is some issue with PHP - I am not sure if PHP processor applies some changes to my query and thus ignores the commit command?

--
Mike