|
|
Subject: Re: Konkani lessons in the GTA - msg#00478
List: culture.region.india.goa
I think Tim de Mello and Joe Vaz should be left in
peace. If we had an Alliance Francaise type
organisation coming out from Goa where there are
standards etc. one would count it as an other story.
If the critics or skeptics are ready to form an AF
type organisation for teaching Concani world wide,
Goans should accept this idea with open arms.
But for goodness sake please let Tim, and Joe who has
had the courage to teach be left alone.
Colaco
> Don't we normally say: Tuka dev borem korun" instead
> of the other way. Or, just "Dev borem korun."
>
__________________________________________________
Yahoo! Plus - For a better Internet experience
http://uk.promotions.yahoo.com/yplus/yoffer.html
##########################################################################
# Send submissions for Goanet to goanet-fPO8gb98cCIdnm+yROfE0A@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
#
# PLEASE remember to stay on-topic (related to Goa), and avoid top-posts #
# More details on Goanet at http://joingoanet.shorturl.com/ #
# Please keep your discussion/tone polite, to reflect respect to others #
##########################################################################
Was this page helpful?
Thread at a glance:
Previous Message by Date:
click to view message preview
NEW ADDRESS...Yet Again!
Dear Muriel & Mario:
Remember this: In the world of commerce the ?Customer? is King. As long as
you let the service provider/supplier get away with substandard services
they will do it.
In a world of fast-paced technological changes, there will be periodical
upgrades, resulting in minor inconveniences. Can these transitions be
smoother? You bet! With a bit of foresight and planning much better
service can be provided. However, like most other things in Goa, there is
hardly a thought put in regarding inconveniences to the public. The Goa
Telecom Telephone directory is just one example, and it?s a ridiculous waste
of funds and effort to issue an already defunct (outdated) phone book.
As a consumer you have all the right to protest, --for you pay for this
service-- and the best way to voice consumer complaints is via mass media ?
the Newspapers and Internet (e-propagation) can play significant roles, to
this end.
Goa can be an ideal state, only if the Goan public is NOT complacent. You
guys are creating awareness -- ?Awareness? being the operative work. I am
glad you are sowing the seeds of awareness that will bear fruit sooner than
later?- voices will be heard and progress will be made!
Best wishes,
Joe Vaz
??????????????????????????????.
anOTHERgoa <goanet-GLn4ZrICqqk@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wirtes:
Date: Thu Jun 26, 2003 4:30pm
Subject: [Goanet] NEW ADDRESS...Yet Again!
[Dear Netters,
Kindly send your messages to our NEW address:
elinks-LMGfRV8PsSU@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
We have just confirmed that till 30th June, BSNL-Goa will not be redirecting
mail from the oldaddress-GLn4ZrICqqk@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx to the newaddress@xxxx, even though they
promised to do so in a message to subscribers.
Till then, can you imagine the plight of 16,000 emailers in Goa? Should we
use the new one and lose mail till the 30th? Or should we wait till the
30th and risk someone using our Sancharnet account because of the open
password they have sent us?
This is the fifth time in six years that a change of email address is being
forced on subscribers. It must be a record of sorts - especially this time
without immediate forwarding facilities to the new address. BSNL in Goa is
either oblivious to the chaos and tremendous hardship caused to subscribers
or they just do not care!
Apologies for the inconvenience. Please do not forget to use our
@sancharnet.in address.
Solidarity.
Muriel & Mario.
_________________________________________________________________
Are you a geek? Are you a techno freak? http://www.msn.co.in/Computing/
##########################################################################
# Send submissions for Goanet to goanet-fPO8gb98cCIdnm+yROfE0A@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx #
# PLEASE remember to stay on-topic (related to Goa), and avoid top-posts #
# More details on Goanet at http://joingoanet.shorturl.com/ #
# Please keep your discussion/tone polite, to reflect respect to others #
##########################################################################
Next Message by Date:
click to view message preview
27 JUNE 2033: GOACOM DAILY NEWS CLIPPINGS
GOACOM DAILY NEWS CLIPPINGS
27 June 2003
MAJOR LANDSLIDE AT SOCORRO: Three pedestrians had a miraculous escape when a
major landslide occurred at Socorro Bobd at 7.30 am on Thursday (June 26),
about 700 metres from the Panjim-Mapusa national highway. A major portion of
the hill on both the sides has caved in resulting in debris, mud and
boulders blocking the entire road connecting the Porvorim Highway Tisko to
Socorro church. (H)
CENTRE TO NUDGE INDUSTRY: The Central government will soon make it
compulsory for industries to actively work to preserve the environment,
Minister of State for Power Jaywantiben Mehta said yesterday. Speaking at
the inaugural session of Greentech Safety Awards and a three-day conference
on environmental safety organised by Delhi-based NGO Greentech Foundation at
Cidade de Goa, Mehta said that her ministry also envisaged greater
initiatives to maintain safe working standards in the country. (GT)
PIMPS, OTHERS ON THE RUN: The police drive against anti-social elements in
and around the red-light area has been hailed by the residents of Vasco.
DySP Vishran Borkar and PI Mahesh Gaonkar rounded up about 50-60 persons
moving suspiciously during the late hours in the red-light area of Baina in
Vasco da Gama. (GT)
POLICE RESCUE MINOR GIRL: Police rescued a minor girl from Ichalkaranji,
Maharashtra, who had been forced into prostitution and tortured for three
years in the Baina red-light area during the last three years. (GT)
HC ISSUED NOTICE TO GOVT: The Panaji bench of Bombay High Court has issued
notices to the State government and others on a Public Interest Litigation
seeking directions in connection with the buildings constructed without
adequate off-street parking facilities in Panaji. (NT)
GOA DRIVES UP THE VEHICLE GRAPH: In March 1998, a total of 2,63,006 vehicles
were registered in the State while estimates put this year's figures at
approximately 3.75 lakh, an increase of more than 1 lakh vehicles in five
years. These figures, however, do not include the floating population of
vehicles that enter the State on a daily basis, transporting tourists and
goods. (GT)
GOVT PROVIDES RS.1 CR TO MAPUSA BANK: The State government has provided a
share capital of Rs.1 crore to the Mapusa Urban Co-operative Bank yesterday.
Meanwhile, the bank has decided to wind up its two branches at Canacona and
Cuncolim and amalgamate these branches into its Margao branch from July 1.
(NT)
UGDP PARTY HEADQUARTERS: The headquarters of the United Goans Democratic
Party in Margao received two party functionaries, including a Tourism
Minister on Thursday evening. It was Ms Joba Majhi, the UGDP MLA in the
Jharkhand Assembly holding portfolios of Tourism and Social Welfare.
Accompanying her was the convenor of the party in Jharkhand, Nazam Ansari.
"It was just a courtesy call to our party leadership. For us, unlike other
political outfits who turn to Delhi, Goa is our party headquarters," Ansari
said. (H)
ESCAPE UNHURT: The driver and the cleaner of a truck loaded with coal had a
miraculous escape after it came down the Chicalim slope near Pai Nursing
Home on 25 June night. (NT)
HYPNOSIS TO GRILL OFFENDERS: What can the police do if they face a tough
prisoner who does not spill the beans during interrogation? Now they are
looking at hypnosis to break the mental barriers. If a new idea becomes a
reality, the cops may soon start focusing their investigations on the minds
of criminals. (GT)
CARAMBOLIM LAKE: The picturesque Carambolim lake which attracts exotic
migratory birds wears a desolate look, even as the annual avian season is
scheduled to begin in les than three months from now. The sweeping Salvinia
weed engulfs a sizeable portion of the lake causing a hindrance to birds who
love to make this lake their abode between October to April away from the
cold northern hemisphere. (H)
BAD ROADS IN BORDA: Unsatisfied with the Borda road work of the PWD
engineers and other concerned authorities, the Borda Citizens Welfare
Committee has decided to approach the vigilance department. (NT)
CERTIFICATE FROM FF: Welcome to Velim, the home of two-time former Cuncolim
MLA and eminent Freedom Fighter, Rock Santan Fernandes. He is among the
handful of Freedom Fighters, whose certificate can bolster or mar the
prospects of many a would be registered Freedom Fighters. (H)
INTERIM MINIMUM LAND RATES: The State government has extended the date for
inviting the objections and suggestions from general public over the
proposed draft statement for finalization of the interim minimum land rates
by another 15 days. (NT)
KRC TRAIN MISHAP: Altogether 50 individuals have lost their lives in the
Konkan railway accident. For some, it is the end of everything. At least
three families have been wiped out in this accident. This includes the
family of four of Lalloo Gabal from Nashik. For Mr and Mrs Kadam and for
their newborn baby boy, the special train journey proved to be "the end".
All three died in the ill-fated train accident. The third is Gauns family,
husband, wife and two children from Imbrahmpur, Pernem. (H)
ADMISSIONS TO PROFESSIONAL COLLEGES: Over 1500 students are trying to seek
admissions to five professional colleges in the State, having a total seat
capacity of 940. Like previous years the rush is for engineering course,
which has 810 seats in three colleges. (NT)
FRIDAY BALCAO: Friday Balcao, the fortnightly discussion event to be held on
June 27, at Goa DESC, Mapusa at 4 pm, will feature the topics, should the
government ban ragging in colleges.
BHAJIYA FESTIVAL: Ice N Spice of Hotel Delmon has welcome the monsoons by
celebrating Bhajiya Festival. On offer are various types of bhajiyas
including the local Kanda Bhajim and mirchi. Other varieties include moon
dal bhajiyas, ajwain and patra bhajiyas from Gujarat, Rajasthani mirchi,
pancher pakoda from Utter Pradesh and bondas from South. (H)
S P O R T S
NO GOAN IN JUNIOR TEAM: Twenty-eight footballers hold the key to the success
of Indian football in five to seven years time. But no Goan footballers
could fit into the 28 footballers, who would figure in the Indian under-18
team gearing for the Milk Cup in Ireland. Three Goans, Welsey D'Costa,
Santan Fernandes and Bevan D'Mello, have not found favour with the
selectors. Most of the footballers have been drawn from last year's under-17
Indian team. The third phase of the game is due to start in Goa from June
28. (H)
PY NUVEM IN FINAL: Parish Youth, Nuvem, scored a well-deserving 3-1 win over
Dando Boys, Colva, to enter the finals of the Alvernaz Alemao memorial
football tournament in Benaulim. (H)
D E A T H S
26 June: Margao-Mesta Bhatt: JOSE PEREIRA, husband of Rosy, father of
Jude/Silvana, Ben/Melinda, Suzie/Xavier and Steve.
26 June: Taleigao: ANAND R PAI (86), husband of Premabai, father of
Manohar/Medha, late Shradha/Shashikant Thali, Bharati/Mahesh Kaisari and
Pratibha/Umesh Sakhardande.
26 June: Reis Magos: KALINI RAMCHANDRA MAYEKAR, wife of Ramchandra
(Sarpanch of Reis Magos).
G O A W E A T H E R
Temp: 26.5 deg C (79.7 deg F) at 08.00 am in Assagao.
Max Temp: 31.1 deg C, Min Temp: 22.8 deg C; Humidity: 97% (Official
figures for yesterday)
Rainfall so far: 726.8 mm
Weather: The morning is quite bright with sunlight in patches. It seems
to rain mostly in the evening.
Courtesy: H=Herald, NT=The Navhind Times, GT= Gomantak Times
JOEL D'SOUZA, Assagao-Goa-India.
Website: www.goacom.com
Goacom News Clippings at: http://www.goacom.com/news
Have you checked the latest edition of Audio-Video
Webzine GoaNOW: http://www.goacom.com/goanow
##########################################################################
# Send submissions for Goanet to goanet-fPO8gb98cCIdnm+yROfE0A@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
#
# PLEASE remember to stay on-topic (related to Goa), and avoid top-posts #
# More details on Goanet at http://joingoanet.shorturl.com/ #
# Please keep your discussion/tone polite, to reflect respect to others #
##########################################################################
Previous Message by Thread:
click to view message preview
Re: Konkani lessons in the GTA
Eugene Correia goanet-GLn4ZrICqqk@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Writes:
Joe Vaz finds no problem with the Konkani Tim de Mello
wrote. That's the real problem with Konkani,
particularly between the spoken Konkani and the
written Konkani.
Don't we normally say: Tuka dev borem korun" instead
of the other way. Or, just "Dev borem korun." Literal
Konkani has some form.
One of the accusations from anti-Konkani people is
that Konkani lacks formal grammar. But Konkani
scholars have proved this wrong.
To each his own Konkani.>
Peace,
Eugene<
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sure, I don?t have any problem with the Konkani Tim de Mello wrote (except
for the misspelled words).
There is no problem in saying:
?Dev borem korum, tuka ani tuje familik.? or
?Tuka and tujea familik dev borem korum.?
Just as one may say:
?Thanks, to you and your family? or
?To you and your family ?thank you (all).?
The primary purpose of any language is to communicate, and as long as one
person understands the other ?that purpose will have been served. Tim?s
version of ?Thank you? has done just that. Unless of course if Tim is
venturing to write a textbook in Konkani, which may warrant the critique. :)
I am bemused how a couple words of Konkani can create such a ruckus among
Goa-netters. Assuming that Eugene lives abroad, I wonder if he knows the
"Konkani" taught in Goa schools? If we want to learn/speak the official
Konkani we will have to learn it the way it is introduced/taught now in
schools.
Best Wishes,
Joe Vaz
_________________________________________________________________
Feeling lost and loneyl? Need a little astro guidance?
http://www.msn.co.in/Astrology/
##########################################################################
# Send submissions for Goanet to goanet-fPO8gb98cCIdnm+yROfE0A@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx #
# PLEASE remember to stay on-topic (related to Goa), and avoid top-posts #
# More details on Goanet at http://joingoanet.shorturl.com/ #
# Please keep your discussion/tone polite, to reflect respect to others #
##########################################################################
Next Message by Thread:
click to view message preview
Re: Konkani lessons in the GTA
Joe vaz writes:
>
> The primary purpose of any language is to
> communicate, and as long as one
> person understands the other ?that purpose will have
> been served. Tim?s
> version of ?Thank you? has done just that. Unless of
> course if Tim is
> venturing to write a textbook in Konkani, which may
> warrant the critique. :)
>
> I am bemused how a couple words of Konkani can
> create such a ruckus among
> Goa-netters. Assuming that Eugene lives abroad, I
> wonder if he knows the
> "Konkani" taught in Goa schools? If we want to
> learn/speak the official
> Konkani we will have to learn it the way it is
> introduced/taught now in
> schools.
>
> Best Wishes,
>
> Joe Vaz
---
I do live abroad, but as I explained in my earlier
post that I had the opportunity to read every week
Konkani papers. When I was growing up we used to get
Udentechem Nektr, published by the Archidioese of
Bombay and edited by Mgr. Ayres Fernandes, who was at
my parish of St. Francis Xavier, Dabul.
Mgr. Fernandes was influenced by Prof. Joaquim Antonio
Fernandes who taught Konkani at the Parel seminary. I
too came under the learned professor's influence when
I was a young man.
I often met the professor at the Ave Maria newspaper
office and I was a good listener to the discussion he
conducted with people who normally used to drop in the
newspaper's office. I often asked him questions and he
was patient enought to reply. He encouraged me to
write in Konkani. I tried and with a mixture of
Konkani and English I submitted some pieces to Goa
Times and Ave Maria. However, they were rigorously
edited and published in Konkani. I was pleased.
I was even invited to be member of the Konkani Bhasha
Mandal, but I refused saying that I am not a Konkani
writer.
Prof. Fernandes lived in the Padamsee Bldg on Princess
St, not far from Ave Maria press which was next to the
Our Lady of Doloures Church in Dhobitalao.
Even the well-known Konkani writer Fr. Antonio Pereira
has acknowledged that his Konkani writing has been
influenced by the professor. Also Fr. Morena de Souza.
Prof. Fernandes and Valavlikar were friends.
I have his books, Poilem Konknni PustoK and Dusrem
Konknni Pustok. Besides, I also have his other book on
how to write Konkani called Konknni Nad-Xastr (Konkani
Phonetics). Modern scholars have dismissed this book
was lacking in methodology. It has just 77 pages.
He left lot of notes and other literary writings.
After his death, I talked to his daughter to get them
published. She informed that her brother has them. I
told her that to donate to an institution or something
for use by future scholars. I felt they were selfish.
I think his writings are lost forever for those who
would have benefitted from them.
For Vaz, language, as long as it's understood, is
matter of no concern if spoken the right way or wrong.
When someone asks you, "Tujem nanv kitem" I believe
you would reply, "Joe Vaz mujem navn". I did
understand the reply and, going by your standards,
that's all matters, thank you.
One good book to start with is Let's Learn Konkani, by
S. J. Borkar, which Jorge has also mentioned. I have
also gone through Konkani Vyakaran by Pro. R.k. Rao,
and Konkani Self Teacher by Mohan D. Karapurkar, whose
blurb says, "a perfect guide to learn Konkanni
)dv-nagri and Roman) through english vice-versa."
Mind you, no ruckus was created. Any debate discussion
is good for the health of this forum or it will die
from idleness. As long as we show courtesy and not
indulge in name-calling or hitting someone below the
belt, discussions should be welcomed.
I often wish I was young again to go to Goa schools
and learn the language. I struggle to read the
devnagri script as I studied Hindi and Marathi in
school. To keep my touch with Hindi I used to borrow
Hindi mags from the library. But that was more than 10
years ago. Now I pick up the Hindi language paper
called Hindi Times and another Hindi/English paper,
Hello Canada, to read. But it's a painful exercise to
get familiar again with Hindi.
Joe, no personal offence meant. Just a long-winded
info.
Eugene Correia
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! DSL - Now only $29.95 per month!
http://sbc.yahoo.com
##########################################################################
# Send submissions for Goanet to goanet-fPO8gb98cCIdnm+yROfE0A@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
#
# PLEASE remember to stay on-topic (related to Goa), and avoid top-posts #
# More details on Goanet at http://joingoanet.shorturl.com/ #
# Please keep your discussion/tone polite, to reflect respect to others #
##########################################################################
|
|