[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: CALCITE-2458 Use of Kotlin for unit tests

The following is for the reference purposes, and there's not a single
intend to accuse anybody of doing something (e.g. miscalculations or
My calculations might be off so please correct me if you think that is

1) Calcite includes 16 committers + 19 PMC. Most of them were silent.

2) http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/calcite-dev/201809.mbox/thread?2
shows (as of time when I create this message) that the thread has 14
messages 5 of which were generated by me

3) Apache voting (see
https://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html#votes-on-code-modification )
explicitly recommends to use whole numbers for voting on code modifications.

4) No-one killed a proposal with a veto

5) Most of replies were around +-0, except Michael who was +0.5 and Jacques
who was -0.9 (note that he explicitly declares he does not veto the change)
To my best knowledge:
Michael Mior +0.5 (binding)
Laurent Goujon -0 (binding)
Enrico Olivelli -0
Jacques Nadeau -0.9 (binding)
Vladimir Sitnikov ++1 (binding)

6) I'm sure we don't really want to discuss this. I suggest we don't spend
time on splitting hairs here.
Apparently there's not that many people who care enough to spend time on
this discussion.